Affordable Access

Access to the full text

Vertragstypenzwang im Code civil? Die Gültigkeit gegenseitiger Verträge in der Judikatur der Freien Stadt Krakau (1815–1846)

Authors
  • Dziadzio, Andrzej
Type
Published Article
Journal
Zeitschrift der Savigny-Stiftung für Rechtsgeschichte: Germanistische Abteilung
Publisher
De Gruyter
Publication Date
Jul 26, 2022
Volume
139
Issue
1
Pages
270–283
Identifiers
DOI: 10.1515/zrgg-2022-0011
Source
De Gruyter
Keywords
Disciplines
  • Miszellen
License
Yellow

Abstract

Contract-nominalism in the Code civil? The validity of bilateral agreements in the judicature of the courts of the Free City of Krakow (1815–1846). The courts of the Free City of Kraków, when applying Article 1325 of the Code civil, adopted a different direction from the courts in Baden or the French judiciary, both of which modified its strict content. In addition to the differences between the Polish, German and French judicatures, there were inconsistencies between individual judgements relating to the form of bilateral agreements in all three cases. As a result, the citizens of the Free City of Kraków, the Grand Duchy of Baden, or France, had no sufficient certainty as to whether their contracts would be adequately protected in the event of a dispute between the parties. The analyzed cases show a convergence of the jurisprudence of the Baden and French courts, which presented a bolder approach to the issue of the validity of bilateral agreements, thereby protecting the Code Civil principle of the freedom of contracts. Kraków courts refrained from such a creative interpretation of the article 1325 and based their rulings on its literal wording. This was partly due to the fact that Polish scholars and judges did not have easy access to the achievements of French jurisprudence at that time. The courts of Baden adjudicated in more favourable conditions, because French and German legal thoughts on the implementation of Code Civil intertwined and complemented each other.

Report this publication

Statistics

Seen <100 times