Affordable Access

Informed decision making in persons acquitted not guilty by reason of insanity.

Authors
  • Elliott, R L
  • Nelson, E
  • Fitch, W L
  • Scott, R
  • Wolber, G
  • Singh, R
Type
Published Article
Journal
The Bulletin of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law
Publication Date
Jan 01, 1993
Volume
21
Issue
3
Pages
309–320
Identifiers
PMID: 8148513
Source
Medline
License
Unknown

Abstract

Deciding to raise an insanity defense carries serious consequences. This is especially true for persons charged with minor offenses, for whom an acquittal not guilty by reason of insanity (NGRI) might lead to a longer period of incarceration than would conviction. Before raising an insanity defense, a defendant should be provided with information necessary to make an informed decision and should be competent to understand the consequences of the verdict. This study attempted, through retrospective review and concurrent evaluation, to determine the degree to which trial courts in Virginia attended to these important aspects of informed decision making before finding defendants charged with misdemeanors NGRI. The study also attempted to assess the degree to which defendants were competent and informed at the time of adjudication. In most instances, trial courts did not consider defendants' competence to make decisions regarding the insanity defense and did not consider whether defendants were informed about the consequences of a successful insanity defense at the time of adjudication. The average length of stay for these patients was (at least) 21 months; most would have been released earlier had they been committed civilly rather than committed as a result of insanity pleas. We stress the need to educate judges, attorneys and forensic evaluators to the importance of considering defendants competence to plead insanity and of providing information about the consequences of a successful plea. We also propose that laws be changed to recognize the importance of these elements in the decision making process regarding pleas of insanity.

Report this publication

Statistics

Seen <100 times