Body stakes : an existential ethics of care in living with biometrics and AI
- Authors
- Publication Date
- Jan 01, 2024
- Identifiers
- DOI: 10.1007/s00146-022-01550-8
- OAI: oai:DiVA.org:liu-188770
- Source
- DiVA - Academic Archive On-line
- Keywords
- Language
- English
- License
- Green
- External links
Abstract
This article discusses the key existential stakes of implementing biometrics in human lifeworlds. In this pursuit, we offer a problematization and reinvention of central values often taken for granted within the "ethical turn" of AI development and discourse, such as autonomy, agency, privacy and integrity, as we revisit basic questions about what it means to be human and embodied. Within a framework of existential media studies, we introduce an existential ethics of care-through a conversation between existentialism, virtue ethics, a feminist ethics of care and post-humanist ethics-aiming to deepen and nuance our understanding of the human behind "human-centered" AI directives. The key argument is that biometrics implicates humans through unprecedented forms of objectification, through which the existential body-the relational, intimate and frail human being-is at risk. We interrogate these risks as they become visible at three sites where embodied humans are challenged by biometrics, and thus where the existential body is challenged by the biometric body. This occurs through reductionism (biometric passports nailing bodies to identities, removing human judgment and compromising agency at the AI border), enforced transparency (smart home assistants surveying human intimacies and invading intimate spaces in the bedroom) and the breaching of bodily integrity (chipping bodies to capture sensory data, challenging the very concept of bodily integrity through self-invasive biohacking). Our existential ethics of care is importantly not a solutionist list of principles or suggestions, but a manifesto for a way of thinking about the ethical challenges of living with biometrics in todays world, by raising the right questions. We argue that a revitalized discussion of the basic existential stakes within human lived experience is needed and should serve as the foundation on which comprehensive frameworks can be built to address the complexities and prospects for ethical machines, responsible biometrics and AI. / <p>Funding Agencies|Uppsala University; Marianne and Marcus Wallenberg Foundation [MMW2019.0012]</p>