Affordable Access

Antidotes all the way down?

Euskal Herriko Unibertsitatea / Universidad del País Vasco
Publication Date


This paper concerns the relationship between dispositions and ceteris paribus laws. Dispositions are related to conditionals. Typically a fragile glass will break if struck with force. But possession of the disposition does not entail the corresponding simple (subjunctive or counterfactual) conditional. The phenomena of finks and antidotes show that an object may possess the disposition without the conditional being true. Finks and antidotes may be thought of as exceptions to the straightforward relation between disposition and conditional. The existence of these phenomena are easy to demonstrate at the macro-level. But do they exist at the fundamental level also? While fundamental finkish dispositions may be excluded fairly straight-forwardly, the existence of fundamental antidotes is more open. Nonetheless I conclude that the phenomenon is likely to be less widespread than at the macro level and that fundamental antidotes may be eliminable. According to the dispositional essentialist, the laws of nature can be explained by taking natural properties to be essentially dispositional. This account can be extended to show that the existence of finks and antidotes explains ceteris paribus laws. Consequently the existence or otherwise of fundamental finks and antidotes sheds some light on the question of whether fundamental laws may also be ceteris paribus laws.

There are no comments yet on this publication. Be the first to share your thoughts.


Seen <100 times

More articles like this

It's narrative all the way down.

on The American journal of bioeth... August 2007

[Savings all the way down].

on Sygeplejersken May 14, 1980

It's frogs all the way down

on Cognition Jan 01, 1983
More articles like this..