Affordable Access

Book Abstracts

Cniversity of Windsor
Publication Date


INFORMAL LOGIC XV!.3, Fall 1994 Book Abstracts Feldman, Richard ( 1993). Reason & Argu- ment. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall. ISBN 0-13-767229-2. Reason & Argument is a textbook for rea- soning, critical thinking, and informal logic courses. It contains three main sections. The first introduces the conceptual background necessary for understanding and analyzing arguments. It includes discussions of epis- temological concepts used in describing and evaluating arguments. This section ad- dresses the naively relativistic ideas of many students which interfere with their ability to reason well. The second main section presents a general method for identifying, reconstructing, and evaluating arguments. The final section applies the method to re- alistic arguments about testimonial, statis- tical, causal, and moral issues. The method of argument analysis developed in the book discourages simplistic labeling and catego- rizing of arguments and encourages careful and constructive analysis. Freeman, James (1992). Thinking Logi- cally: Basic Concepts for Reasoning, 2nd ed. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall. ISBN 0-13-9051 IS-X. This informal logic text begins by distin- guishing three functions of language informati ve/expressi ve/directi ve - and discussing problems of meaning, includ- ing vagueness and ambiguity. Recogniz- ing arguments and their premises and con- clusions follows. Distinguishing the per- suasive force from the logically convinc- ing character of arguments leads to dis- cussing various emotional appeal fallacies including grandstanding, bandwagon, au- thority, ad hominem, ignorance, and slip- pery slope. A full step-by-step discussion of argument diagramming via a circle and arrow technique follows over the next two chapters. We then turn to three central is- sues in argument evaluation - premise acceptability, relevance, and adequate weight. The last includes both inductive and deductive considerations. For each issue we present gener

There are no comments yet on this publication. Be the first to share your thoughts.


Seen <100 times