Affordable Access

Conflicts of Interest: Blumberg’s Response

Environmental Health Perspectives
Environmental Health Perspectives
Publication Date
  • Perspectives
  • Correspondence
  • Design
  • Ecology
  • Economics


workingfrontpgs Association between Air Pollution and Adverse Pregnancy Outcomes in Vancouver In the November 2003 issue of EHP, Liu et al. (2003) concluded that “relatively low concentrations of gaseous air pollutants are associated with adverse effects on birth out- comes.” Although this may be true from a purely statistical sense, there appear to be limitations of this research that suggest cautious interpretation of the findings. Liu et al. (2003) evaluated individual- level birth certificate data, which is an improvement over the ecologic designs of past time-series studies on pollution. However, birth records do not contain most of the variables that are important predictors of low weight and preterm births. These include smoking, alcohol and/or drug abuse, low socioeconomic status (SES), small maternal weight or height, complications of the current or previous pregnancy [e.g., pregnancy-induced hypertension, previous low birth weight (LBW), spontaneous abor- tion], insufficient weight gain during preg- nancy, maternal illness (e.g., fever), and job-related exertion (Berkowitz and Papiernik 1993; Holmes and Soothill 1996; Kramer 1987, 2003; Lang et al. 1996; Moore 2003). Many of these are major fac- tors that substantially affect risk. For exam- ple, maternal smoking during pregnancy, which has a prevalence of 10–20% in the United States (Ebrahim et al. 2000; O’Campo et al. 1995), is associated with a 2- to 4-fold increase in risk of LBW or growth restriction (Kramer 1987; Lang et al. 1996; Nordentoft et al. 1996). Therefore, there is considerable room for uncontrolled confounding that might account for the small odds ratio of 1.05–1.10 observed by Liu et al. (2003). Liu et al. (2003) argued that uncon- trolled or residual confounding is an unlikely explanation for their results because a) there is no evidence that these factors are associated with air pollution; b) ecologic measures of SES did not modify the associations; and c) “there were only slight differences between crude

There are no comments yet on this publication. Be the first to share your thoughts.


Seen <100 times