Affordable Access

Receiving advice on matters of taste: Similarity, majority influence, and taste discrimination

  • Musicology


People routinely consider the opinions of others prior to making decisions on matters of taste (e.g., a restaurant or movie). Our theoretical framework highlights the role of two sources, social (majority) influence and similarity among advisors, in such decisions. We suggest that individuals' use of these sources depends on their taste discrimination. While highly discriminating judges seek the opinion of a similar advisor rather than the majority opinion, less discriminating judges do so less. In four studies participants made musical choices based on recommendations. The studies document the great appeal of behavioral similarity and the role of demographic similarity. They also provide evidence for the discrimination hypothesis. A formal simulation is developed to account for the relationship between taste discrimination and the predictive accuracy of the majority and of similar advisors. The results shed light on theories of advice utilization and social influence, and are connected with applications involving personalized recommendation systems.

There are no comments yet on this publication. Be the first to share your thoughts.


Seen <100 times

More articles like this

Receiving advice on matters of taste: Similarity,...

on Organizational Behavior and Hu... Jan 01, 2011

Receiving other people’s advice: Influence and ben...

on Organizational Behavior and Hu... Jan 01, 2004

Appeals and advice on pension matters.

on AARN news letter April 1987

Influence of similarity of choice-point and goal c...

on Journal of Comparative and Phy... August 1953
More articles like this..