Affordable Access

Publisher Website

Current modeling practice may lead to falsely high benchmark dose estimates

Regulatory Toxicology and Pharmacology
DOI: 10.1016/j.yrtph.2014.03.004
  • Benchmark Dose
  • Simulation
  • Risk Assessment
  • Dose–Effect
  • Point Of Departure
  • Chemistry


Abstract Benchmark dose (BMD) modeling is increasingly used as the preferred approach to define the point-of-departure for health risk assessment of chemicals. As data are inherently variable, there is always a risk to select a model that defines a lower confidence bound of the BMD (BMDL) that, contrary to expected, exceeds the true BMD. The aim of this study was to investigate how often and under what circumstances such anomalies occur under current modeling practice. Continuous data were generated from a realistic dose–effect curve by Monte Carlo simulations using four dose groups and a set of five different dose placement scenarios, group sizes between 5 and 50 animals and coefficients of variations of 5–15%. The BMD calculations were conducted using nested exponential models, as most BMD software use nested approaches. “Non-protective” BMDLs (higher than true BMD) were frequently observed, in some scenarios reaching 80%. The phenomenon was mainly related to the selection of the non-sigmoidal exponential model (Effect=a·eb·dose). In conclusion, non-sigmoid models should be used with caution as it may underestimate the risk, illustrating that awareness of the model selection process and sound identification of the point-of-departure is vital for health risk assessment.

There are no comments yet on this publication. Be the first to share your thoughts.


Seen <100 times

More articles like this

Current modeling practice may lead to falsely high...

on Regulatory Toxicology and Phar...

Human activities that may lead to high inhaled int...

on Environmental toxicology and p... December 1997

Human activities that may lead to high inhaled int...

on Environmental Toxicology and P... Jan 01, 1997

Benchmark dose of lead inducing anemia at the work...

on Risk analysis : an official pu... August 2005
More articles like this..